Oriflame Beauty Eyeliner Stylo #Black

Hello, how are you today? I'm so happy today because my geo lens has just arriven ^^..
But I must wait till my current lens has expired to try that geo T_T I can't wait to try them soon @@
Back to the topic, nah I bought this eyeliner about 3 months ago since my liquid liner has dried out (that's my favorite eyeliner!! forgout what brand is that)..
This is Oriflame Beauty Eyeliner stylo

I think the applicator is a lil too big :(















Swatch on my hand

 I can draw a thin line with this eyeliner :D but it's lil difficult to draw the thin one..

 After rubbed it.. It smudge -.-"

After I placed my hand under running water tap and I rubbed it..















On my eye

This is when I just applied the eyeliner, I draw a very thin line hehe :p

About 30minutes later, you can see it's starting to smudge at the outer corner of my eye..













What I hate
*It's neither waterproof nor smudgeproof x_x.. on my oily lids it was only last for 1 hour!! And it smudged BEAUTIFULLY :')
*The price is a little too expensive I think :( I bought it for idr 89000
*Doesn't have a cute packaging (I LOVE CUTE PACKAGING *-*)

What I like
*Easy application

Repurchase? ABSOLUTELY NO!!

So what do you think about this eyeliner? Anyone has tried this? I want to know how this eyeliner works on other people since I have oily eyelids ;)